This search began offering a salary range of $150,000 to $180,000 base.
Our client is a Canadian tech startup — and this was their first marketing leadership hire.
Reporting to the Founder/CEO, this role would be a strategic, hands-on key marketer with full ownership. Initially, no direct reports, but a vision to expand the department as the business grew.
The main requirements for this search included:
- Product marketing as the core craft, with real depth in positioning and messaging.
- Experience leading T-shaped across the whole marketing stack. Content, demand generation, growth, social, and editorial authority over everything the company puts out.
- Zero-to-one war stories, ideally having been a FOUNDING marketer at a start-up.
We introduced our client to 6 candidates. These are the 4 they interviewed.
The Acquisition Marketer
$200K base. Asking: $220K to $230K.
- Director of Product Marketing at a small, profitable software business that was acquired late last year, where he had been the first marketer.
- There he cut the sales cycle in half and doubled average contract value, and lifted website-to-SQL conversion by 15%.
- Before that, the second marketer at a twenty-person startup, where he tripled pipeline quarter over quarter, led a team of three, and cut cost per acquisition by 30% on a $75,000 quarterly budget.
The Category Builder
Asking: $180K base, minimum.
- Director of Product Marketing at a Series B marketplace.
- Before that, at an assessment software company, drove $2.5M in revenue through new product go-to-market and hired a team of four product marketers.
- At a restaurant technology business, drove more than $5M in ARR launching new products, raised win rates above 40% and expanded average deal size by 20%, hiring three product marketers to do it.
- Earlier, scaled a consumer hardware line five times over on a $10M global marketing budget.
The T-Shaped Operator
$165K base plus a $15K bonus and $25K in equity. Asking: $175K and up.
- Product marketing at a Canadian fintech of about sixty-five people, as the marketing team of one.
- Before that, the founding product marketer at a company that was later acquired, where, as the first marketing hire, she ended up managing three marketing leaders with associates beneath them.
- Three exits behind her, scaling products through the $1M to $5M revenue range.
The Hire
Offer accepted at a $220,000 base, no bonus, plus 1% of the company on a four-year schedule with a twelve-month cliff, 30 days of paid time off, flexible health benefits, a $1,200 annual spending account and $2,500 toward her own equipment.
- She had been earning $190,000 plus a $20,000 bonus. She asked for $200,000.
- Senior Group Product Marketing Manager at a B2B software platform selling to independent online sellers, where she tripled metered revenue from ad spend inside a year by rewriting the positioning, the ideal customer profile and the pricing and packaging. On the same product, she found that what stopped customers from adopting it was confidence rather than tooling, and lifted adoption 10% among enrolled users.
- Before that, the first product marketer at a B2B SaaS business, where she was part of taking ARR from $1M to more than $15M in three years, built the function out to four product marketers, and covered for the VP of Marketing for nine months, running a $2.5M global marketing and sales budget.
WHY the client said yes to this candidate:
She crushed the whiteboard session.
2 hours at a whiteboard with the founder and the team, working on the business model rather than on her own background. What came back was that she held strong opinions, yet was also collaborative at the same time.
WHY the candidate said yes:
The scope. It was the director-level seat she had targeted for the year, with a function to build and the autonomy to build it, and leadership who openly invited being told they were wrong.
She had also concluded that the strategy where she was working had stopped making sense to her.
And the number she walked away from. While she was interviewing, her employer promoted her: a $40,000 raise plus an equity grant, taking her to roughly $240,000. She took $220,000 and 1% of a much smaller company instead.
Kick-off to accepted offer: 9 weeks.
Are you making your first marketing hire? Book a call.